Mariners' 2004 Draft Review

How Successful Was The 2004 Draft?

The June draft came and went and with the exception of one selection, the Mariners weren't in position to grab much attention. <br><br> Without picks in either of the first two rounds, the M's personnel executives made the best of what they had to work with. <br><br> Now that the season has come and gone, InsidethePark.com takes a look at how the draftees fared in their first action in professional baseball.

When the Mariners turn came up several hours into the draft, Bavasi and Bob Fontaine had a decision to make. Should they take the best player available or play it safe and draft the best signable athlete?

Matt Tuiasosopo's terrific season split between the Arizona Rookie League and the Northwest League is proof that the M's made the correct choice with their first pick, the 93rd overall and the 22nd selection in the third round.

Most clubs passed on Tuiasosopo in fear that he would pass on baseball and enroll at the University of Washington to play quarterback for their storied football program.

Instead, the 18-year-old out of Woodinville High School would sign for 1st-round money and perform like the top talent he was paid as.

In his 28 games with Peoria, Tuiasosopo hit .412/.528/.721 with four home runs and 12 RBI, forcing the club to promote the teenager to challenge his natural skills at the next level.

With the Everett Aqua Sox, Tuiasosopo got off to a torrid start by getting hits in his first four games, including a home run and three doubles. The verdict was in. The kid can hit.

Even after his numbers fell to .248/.336/.386 as the opposing pitchers finally found a few ways to get him out, Tui's season was a stellar success and the transition from the aluminum bat to the wooden sort was over, done with, and quite frankly, never a factor.

Kudos to the M's, not only for drafting the best player on the board, but getting him signed even after it became clear he was looking for a first-round payday that ended up breaking a record for a third-round choice at $2.29 million.

3rd-round, Matt Tuiasosopo, Woodinville, Wash.- Grade: A


In the fourth round the M's pegged University of Houston catcher Robert Johnson as the club's next attempt to solve the long time catching issues.

Johnson signed for $260,000 and bounced between Peoria and Everett and never really got in a groove with the bat. Johnson is still considered a solid defensive talent and his skills as a catch-and-throw backstop are major league projectable.

After a .234/.286/.338 showing in the Northwest League, the 23-year-old was shipped to Peoria to keep him in the lineup on a regular basis.

The consistent playing time didn't help much as Johnson continued to struggle with the bat, as the designated hitter. The .222/.323/.259 showing wasn't what the M's had in mind and neither was the injury problem that limited Johnson to six games behind the plate.

4th Round, Robert Johnson, U. of Houston-Grade: D


Fifth-round pick Mark Lowe pitched out of the bullpen for Everett, after signing for $170,000, and flashed the stuff the M's were hoping to see, but also displayed some inconsistencies. His line (1-2, 4.93, 38K, 38.1ip, 7 saves) wasn't as impressive as his stuff would suggest but the sample size is too small to put too much stock into.

Lowe is actually quite a bit like his namesake, Red Sox right-hander Derek Lowe, using a sinking, low 90's fastball to pound hitters inside and a solid slider to get them out in front and roll over the top.

With a serviceable changeup, the University of Texas-Arlington standout could be a solid starting pitcher that can possibly be groomed as a closer.

Like most pitchers just out of college, Lowe's second season, likely to begin in either Wisconsin or Inland Empire, is the key to the start of his pro career and will shed some light on his prospect status.

5th Round, Mark Lowe, U. Texas-Arlington-Grade: B


Round six produced a speedy outfielder from Grand Rapids, Michigan. Jermaine Brock began his first season as a professional in Peoria after signing for $135,000 and spent most of the season trying to get acclimated to his new surroundings and his performance wasn't indicative of the 18-year-old's talents.

Hitting just .248/.281/.317 with five stolen bases, Brock's job is to get on base at a high rate and use his natural speed to set the table for the bigger hitter. To do so, he must get better at recognizing pitches and focus on making more contact (33 K in 129 PA's). This is something the Ottawa High School product knows, and has an idea of what to do to fix.

"Use my speed, be more patient at the plate and become more of a base hit hitter," Brock told InsidethePark.com. "I should have had more on the bases, but that's just apart of learning the game."

The Mariners would love to see Brock run and hit his way up to the lead off spot and become the next Jamal Strong.

6th Round, Jermaine Brock, Grand Rapids, Michigan-Grade: C-


The next four rounds would net the Mariners three college players and a high schooler from the Puerto Rican Baseball Academy.

Seventh-round choice Sebastian Boucher signed late ($90,000) and didn't play in 2004, but the speed demon from Bethune-Cookman College is expected to provide the farm system with an athletic, experienced outfielder with multiple talents.

Eighth-rounder Marshall Hubbard signed for $85,000 and headed for the Northwest League. Hubbard hit .275/.361/.392 with two home runs for the Everett Aqua Sox, playing 1B. The University of North Carolina product struggled making consistent contact which resulted in 52 strikeouts in 216 plate appearances. The left-handed power, however, will be a welcomed addition to the system as Hubbard gets accustomed to the wooden bat.

Jeffrey Dominguez was the ninth-round pick, and the high-schooler out of Puerto Rico signed ($70,000) and reported to Peoria. Dominguez didn't seem ready for the challenge, hitting just .222/.288/.247 in 45 games.

Dominguez struggled in the field as well, committing 15 errors in 37 games at shortstop and 10 at second base.

The M's 10th-round choice was Delaware State right-hander Eric Carter. Carter went 2-4 in Peoria with a 4.26 ERA in 44.1 innings and struck out 35 after signing for $55,000. Carter's 25 walks was the lone blemish of a successful debut.

The Mariners signed 15 other draftees including 14th-rounder Brent Johnson, OF, UNLV, Chad Fillinger, RHP, Santa Clara U., Jack Arroyo, 2B, Sacramento State, Brandon Green, SS, Wichita State, Mumba Rivera, RHP, Bethune-Cookman, David Hall, OF, San Diego State, Greg Slee, C, Hunting College, Joe Jacobitz, C/OF, U. of San Francisco, Aaron Trolia, RHP, Washington State, Adam Brandt, LHP, Otterbein College, Michael Ciccotelli, LHP, Villanova, Don Clement, RHP, U. of Col. State Pueblo, Marquise Liverpool, Don Bosco Prep, Ramsey, N.J., Harold Williams, LHP, Mt. San Jacinto JC.

  • Johnson played very well with the Everett Aqua Sox showing great athleticism and versatility. Playing in center field and at the hot corner, the former Runnin' Rebel hit .296/.396/.365 with 12 steals and an impressive 33-27 walks-to-strikeouts ratio
  • Fillinger went 2-2 with a 7.16 ERA in his 32.2 innings split between Everett and Wisconsin. The Santa Clara grad did strike out 40 versus just 10 walks and showed the pure stuff of a higher pick
  • Green played 1B, 2B and 3B with the Aqua Sox and displayed some pop (26 extra-base hits) to counter 55 strikeouts. The switch-hitting Green hit .272 and also stole nine bases
  • Arroyo hit .310 in 23 games with Peoria and showed an ability to take a walk and limit strikeouts. Arroyo also stole five bases and played 1B, 2B and 3B defensively
  • Rivera posted a 3.47 ERA in 59 innings in the Northwest League while striking out 48. Rivera made 18 appearances, including five starts and allowed just 44 hits
  • Hall hit .277 for Peoria and drove in 20 runs in just 35 games. The San Diego State product stole eight bases and played 34 games in the outfield
  • Slee combined for a .163 average at three stops (Peoria, Inland Empire, San Antonio) and drove in three runs in 43 at-bats. The 24th-round pick played in just 14 games
  • The switch-hitting Jacobitz logged a .278 average with Peoria, driving in nine runs. Drafted as a catcher, the Bay Area product played 26 games in the outfield
  • Trolia went 2-2 with six saves for Everett, finishing the season with a 4.83 ERA. The Tacoma native allowed 39 hits in 41 innings of 20 appearances
  • Brandt was of the biggest surprises of the draft, posting a 2-1 record with a 3.38 ERA in 21.1 innings. Brandt struck out 26 and walked just eight
  • Ciccotelli's 9.86 ERA looks worse than it really was, especially considering the numbers were put up at three different stop. The left-hander struck out 22 and walked just six in 21 games
  • Clement went 0-4 in 15 games with Peoria after signing out of Pueblo State in Colorado. Clement struck out 17 versus seven walks but allowed 38 hits in 28.1 innings
  • Liverpool (33rd) and Williams (38th) did not play after signing late in the summer


  • Twelfth-round pick, LHP Steve Uhlmansiek, had Tommy John surgery and missed the entire 2004 season and is expected to be ready for spring training in February.

    The Wichita State product is thought to be a potential surprise and many believe the M's saved their draft with Uhlmansiek and Tuiasosopo.

    "Once he's healthy, Uhlmansiek could be another steal," said Baseball America's Executive Editor Jim Callis.

    Overall:
    Considering the lack of picks high in the draft, the Mariners did fairly well for themselves and took a risk in handing a high school kid a record bonus. They were rewarded when Tuiasosopo had a great first season but didn't have much luck with the next seven rounds.

    As is for every draft, it's too early to tell for sure, but the Mariners grade out in the middle of the pack for the 2004 draft.

    Grade: C+

    SeattleClubhouse.com Recommended Stories


    Up Next


    Tweets